You can change just the hall sender. Other ones from other VW's will work although I can't say which ones. I remember making one from a mk2 Golf GTI (most likely an 8v Digifant as I had a few at the time - although KR 16v is also in my mind despite never having one) for my G40. Open it up and take a look, may find the crown has chopped a wire in there (the reason i made one, think i also did it on my brothers GT too).